Common Core Standards
- Reading: Determine a central idea of a text and analyze its development over the course of the text, including how it emerges and is shaped and refined by specific details; provide an objective summary of the text.
- Writing: Write informative/explanatory texts to examine and convey complex ideas, concepts, and information clearly and accurately through the effective selection, organization, and analysis of content.
- What is a summary?
- What are the parts of a Rhetorical Precis? thesis, genre, evidence, author's purpose, tone and audience
GLO’S:
- Self-Directed Learner
- Community Contributor
- Complex Thinker
- Quality Producer
- Effective Communicator
- Effective and Ethical User of Technology
Objectives:
- SWBAT identify the parts of a rhetorical precis: thesis, evidence, author's purpose, tone and intended audience.
- SWBAT write a group rhetorical precis.
Assessment(s) and or Evaluation:
Rhetorical Precis Rubric
5= Exceeds the standards. | 4= Meets the standards. | 3.5= Approaches the standards. | 3=Below the standards. |
Follows format perfectly. (no errors in formatting) | Mostly follows format. (1 error in formatting) | Some parts missing. (2 errors in formatting) | Most parts missing. (3 or more errors in formatting) |
Identifies accurate thesis, evidence, tone and audience as presented by the author. | One error in identifying thesis, evidence, tone and audience as presented by the author. | Two errors in identifying thesis, evidence, tone and audience as presented by the author. | Three or more errors in identifying thesis, evidence, tone and audience as presented by the author. |
No or a few errors in language and conventions. | Some errors in language and conventions. | Some errors in language and conventions that interfere with meaning. | Many errors in language and conventions that interfere with meaning. |
Resources:
15 each Copies of "The Case for The Graduated License" and "I Want a Wife"
- Ask class to raise their hands if they know what a summary is.
- Ask class to raise hand if they had to write a summary before.
- Ask student to tell me in their own words what a summary is.
- Write answers on chart paper.
- Advise students that they will learn a new way of writing a summary called a Rhetorical Precis.
- Ask students to read example precis on blog.
- Read example precis.
- Ask students to identify what they think are the parts of a rhetorical precis in their groups then as a whole class.
- Give students format of what is in a rhetorical precis.
- Read "The Case for Graduated License" silently; annotate for thesis and gist.
- Read Rubric for Rhetorical Precis.
- Model how to write a precis for "The Case for Graduated License.
- Read Rubric for Rhetorical Precis.
- Distribute copies of "I Want a Wife."
- Ask students to read "I Want a Wife," and annotate for gist and to think about the following: What is Brady writing about? Who is she writing for? What is the purpose of writing this piece?
- In pairs students will write precis for "I Want a Wife."
- Give students 25 minutes to read and write precis. Walk around the class to check for understanding.
- Have a couple students share precis.
Closing Procedures
- On a post it ask students to write two things they learned and one thing that confused them.
Teacher’s Reflection on Lesson:
Dear Marissa,
ReplyDeleteJune 27, 2011
Rhetorical Precis
Thank you for your well-scaffolded lesson. Giving students exposure to nonfiction texts and argument are necessary skills under the common core. Thank you for persevering through these difficult yet essential skills.
Best practices include: modeling, brainstorming, guided practice, collaborative work groups, and independent work time.
Sincerely,
Jessica Dahlke
June 27, 2011
ReplyDeleteDear Marissa,
Thanks for sharing your lesson with us. I really enjoyed how you gave us an example at the beginning, then allowed us to do a whole group rhetorical prĂ©cis as a class. This way it gave us confidence and experience on how to do it independently. This gradual release of responsibility was very well played out. I also liked how you made us take notes, and then required us to reference it to show us that note taking is important. You also chose a good article for us to relate to. I wouldn’t necessarily use the content of this lesson with my first graders, but I do use the gradual release of independence. You did an excellent job!
Thank you!
Kristi
Dear Marissa,
ReplyDeleteJune 27, 2011
Rhetorical Precis – Summary
I really enjoyed this lesson, especially because I had never heard of Rhetorical Precis before. This seems like a great method to teach students how to pull out important information out of an article.
You did a wonderful job of introducing the structure through modeling, clear outline and expectations (rubrics).
I could modify this to use in first grade by making students write a sentence stating the opinion of authors.
Thanks!
11/27/11
ReplyDeleteRhetorical Precis
Aloha Marissa,
Very nice lesson! I have not used this process before, and you presented it in such a user friendly way. Great instructional strategy! I really enjoyed the lesson.
Some of the many great teaching strategies I observed: guided instruction, 'I do, we do, you do', checking for understanding, positive feedback, and collaborative learning.
Thank you for sharing this lesson that I can and will replicate!
Beth
Dear Marissa
ReplyDeleteI liked how you gave us an example of what you were talking about and let us decide what we think should be in the specific summary, and then let us see how that compared to what was required.
Best Practices:
Group discussion
Look at example and decide what needs to be in format
Direct teach what need
Individual work
Review of rubric
Lets write together THEN do on own
I could lower this lesson to my 1st grade level by doing this for re-tell to prepare them for the DRA reading test they take 3x a year in my class, character names, setting, and events in order.
Thank you!
Jessie
Dear Marissa,
ReplyDeleteThank you for your lesson today. I enjoyed the challenge of feeling like I was in high school again!
Best practices I saw:
*Showing us the rubric ahead of time
*Expecting your students to take notes
*Calling on the students who were talking
*Modeling the activity ahead of time
*Allowing for group discussion/collaboration
*Exit passes as a method of student reflection/clarification
I probably won't do this lesson with my third graders. We do do constructed responses with a specific format for sentences.
Thanks so much,
Shawna
June 27, 2011
ReplyDeleteAloha Marissa,
This was a great lesson. The steps involved in writing a rhetorical precis were clearly defined and facilitated the actual process. I wish I would have had teachers like you in high school. It would have made college a lot easier.
Mahalo Marissa
Cecilia
Great lesson Marissa!
ReplyDeleteNever knew what a rhetorical precis is and how to make one.
Enjoyed both articles too.
BEST practices abound: initial questioning (KWL?), identifying elements
(author, thesis, evidence, etc.), use of technology (checking blog), pair-
and-share, modeling first precis, then writing our second precis. Well-
sequenced and scaffolded. The "slide" you shared on the four sentences
would have helped me since I did not take good notes. Perhaps add
that slide in your lesson plan?
I can definately use this with my middle school students. MAHALO.
Marissa this is an awesome lesson and my partner made it a little easier for me. But I also saw how we can help by reminding each other (students) how to take some words from the question or format because that's how we show the teacher we listening!!!
ReplyDelete